'A mixture from zero to infinity': Physicists split apart a photon — and ended up with an improbable swarm of particles

Physicists recently wondered what would happen if you tried to split a photon ‪—‬ and they found some unexpected behavior that may transform the way we think about particles.

The experiment, in which researchers simulated a photon being sliced by a shutter under various conditions, showed that a severed photon can lead to a complex mixture of zero to infinitely-many photons — raising some big questions about the nature of particle interactions.

Photons are elementary packets of light, which means they are not made up of anything else. So what does it even mean to try splitting a photon? It may be possible thanks to wave-particle duality — a core principle of quantum mechanics, the bizarre physics of the very small.

According to wave-particle duality, a photon is not only a particle but also a wave. Using theoretical calculations, the researchers investigated what would happen if you sent this photon through a shutter and closed it while the photon was passing through, effectively cutting off the tail end of the photon wave.

"I think that most physicists would expect there to be a certain probability that you have zero photons and a certain probability that you have a single photon left after you have done this," Johannes Skaar, co-author of the new study and a professor of theoretical physics at the University of Oslo, told Live Science. "And that is approximately true, but it is not exactly true."

What are the chances?

This brings up another strange aspect of quantum mechanics: its probabilistic nature. Particles exist as a cloud of probabilities stretching to infinity. Until a particle is observed, its properties, such as its position or energy, are in a superposition of possible values; all we can know are the chances of finding it in a certain state.

Through their calculations, Skaar and his colleagues determined how cutting a photon affects these probabilities. In their study, recently accepted in the journal Physical Review Letters, they found that it would create a complex mixture of photon states, including one with an infinite number of photons.

Each of these states has a probability that depends on how quickly the shutter cuts the photon. The expected number of photons becomes infinite only if the shutter is closed infinitely quickly. For realistic shutter speeds, even a thousand photons would be extremely unlikely.

This may sound very strange, but the quantum physicists were unfazed. In fact, what surprised Skaar and his colleagues was what happens if you make measurements of the cut photon from different perspectives.

"When you measure from one side of the shutter, then it will look like a single photon state," Skaar said. "Then, on the other side, it will look like a vacuum state — that means no photons. And that is very strange because the actual state globally is this mixture from zero to infinity."

Changing how we think about particles

The fact that these complex mixtures can be treated locally as very simple states raises fundamental questions about the nature of particles. Skaar said they are still reckoning with the full extent of these implications and they are now considering how this process could play out for other quantum particles, such as electrons.

They hope that by following this theoretical thread through, they may be able to develop a neater way of describing particle interactions. Currently, particles' infinite stretching means they have been interacting for an infinite amount of time. This then poses a problem for causality ‪—‬ the order of cause and effect ‪—‬ in particle interactions, the team said.

These new theoretical photons with a cutoff tail would not have this problem, meaning the causal link in an interaction would be clear, Skaar said. He admitted that there is much more work to be done to develop the theoretical description of this interaction. However, the new result is an important step toward describing particle interactions with a clear causal relationship, which Skaar described as the team's "ultimate goal."