A Rennaissance-era version of the Madonna and Child. New research may help explain why everyone can be moved by art even though we react differently to different things.
Credit: The de Brecy Trust
As they say, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, however, the experience of being moved by art seems universal. A new neurological study offers some insight into this aesthetic paradox.
The results indicate that connecting deeply to a work of art activates the same part of everyone's brain. However, part of the brain activated by such strong aesthetic appeal is associated with personal reflection, the researchers found.
A team of researchers from New York University showed study subjects 109 images of works of art from a variety of cultures, historical periods, styles and depicting a variety of subjects. Using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), the researchers monitored blood flow in the subjects' brains as they viewed the images and rated them on a scale of 1 to 4 scale, with 4 as the highest, in response to the question: "How strongly does this painting move you?"
"Your job is to give your gut-level response, based on how much you find the painting beautiful, compelling, or powerful," the team instructed.
To explore individual differences in aesthetic reactions after the brain scan was complete, the researchers asked subjects to rate the degree to which each work of art evoked nine emotions: joy, pleasure, sadness, confusion, awe, fear, disgust, beauty and the sublime.
The experiments confirmed the old saying.
"Aesthetic judgments for paintings are highly individual, in that paintings experienced as moving differ widely across people," wrote the team, which included NYU researchers Edward Vessel, Gabrielle Starr and Nava Rubin.
The brain scans offered insight into the origin of the aesthetic experience. If a painting merited a 4, distinct patterns emerged in the scans. In particular, these included an increase in activity in regions of the brain belonging to the "default mode network," a network of areas associated with inward contemplation and self-assessment.
It appears that aesthetic experiences activate the brain in the same way for everyone, but the parts activated include those linked with the intensely subjective and personal nature of aesthetics, helping explain why these experiences are both universal and highly individualized, the researchers write in a study published online March 12 in the journal Frontiers in Human Neuroscience.