Reducing Jet Noise By Controlling Turbulence

CREDIT: Dreamstime View full size image

This Behind the Scenes article was provided to LiveScience in partnership with the National Science Foundation.

Airlines and aircraft manufacturers are under increasing pressure to keep noise levels low for airport personnel and for people in surrounding neighborhoods.

In fact, about every 10 years the International Civil Aviation Organization, whose recommendations influence policies in the United States and abroad, reduces the maximum noise an airplane can produce before it can be certified and sold to commercial airlines.

Aircraft are barely able to meet the current levels now. When the noise levels drop again in a few years, no one has a ready-made solution.

Airplane waves

On the surface, sound is a relatively simple phenomenon. A mechanical wave travels through a compressible medium, such as air, and reaches our eardrums where it is converted into an electric signal and interpreted by the brain. When it is generated by an airplane's jet engines, how can it be controlled without impacting the performance of the aircraft?

Daniel Bodony, an assistant professor of aerospace engineering at The University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.
CREDIT: Courtesy of Daniel Bodony, The University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

View full size image

Daniel Bodony, along with Jon Freund, and Jeonglae Kim, all of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, is working on this very issue. Bodony is part of a NASA-funded effort to lessen jet engine noise by controlling the unsteady movement of air, also known as turbulence.

Instead of working in a wind tunnel or laboratory, the team uses the Ranger supercomputer at the Texas Advanced Computing Center to simulate the evolution of turbulence-generated sound waves from jet engine exhaust. The simulations help explain how sound is generated on the most basic level, and also how it can be controlled using a new device.

"We're studying the controlled jet and the uncontrolled jet to understand what changes between them," Bodony said. "That's what experiments can't currently do and what is missing from our understanding of the science."

Simulating flight

Bodony, Freund and Kim use a numerical technique called "large eddy simulation" to simulate the motion of the air around the jet. The simulations show the amount of turbulence flowing in the jet and, importantly, the amount of sound that this turbulence creates.

"Unfortunately, the noise is not generated where you can control it directly, so you have to add a control someplace else, like on the nozzle, and tickle the flow in such a way that the sound is reduced at a later spot in the jet," Bodony explained.

Small, well-timed disturbances added to an uncontrolled Mach 1.3 turbulent jet (left) result in the quieter, controlled jet (right). Though only subtly different, the controlled jet is producing 30 percent less noise as visualized by the black-and-white contours of dilatation, a measure of air's compression rate. The sound-generating turbulence, as indicated by the vorticity, is shown as color.
CREDIT: Courtesy of Daniel Bodony, The University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

View full size image

After conducting four years of research, Bodony and his collaborators have developed a novel technique to determine the optimal controller required to reduce jet noise. The controller is a plasma actuator based on those developed by colleagues at Ohio State — something like a giant spark plug — that alters the sound field by injecting heat.

Reducing sound

"We can't squash the turbulence," Bodony said. "Our controllers aren't that strong and it may not even be possible or desirable. As a result, we add additional perturbations to reorganize the pre-existing disturbances, so that the unsteady forces and stresses within the fluid are less."

The simulations on Ranger determined the ideal timing and strength of the perturbations to reduce the engine's radiated sound without significantly altering its thrust. The first round of improvements showed the potential to reduce jet noise by three decibels, or the equivalent of 30 percent.

"We can reduce the noise from these jets as well as the absolute best that has been found experimentally by trial and error," said Bodony.

Active control

Bodony is confident that with further refinements, his group will be able to reduce the noise level even further. They are also working to develop the system into an active flow control device, with the ability to turn on or off, or change the strength of the control, based on changing conditions. Results of the group's theoretical and simulation work were published online in the Journal of Sound and Vibration in Feb. 2011, along with several conference papers and additional journal articles under peer review.

The design insights that Bodony uncovered are expected to reduce the sound levels on "N+3" generation aircraft, NASA's shorthand for aircraft fielded three generations in the future. Bodony expects such a device, if successful, to enter the market in 10 to 15 years.

If that sounds long, consider that the newly released Boeing 787, the first commercial airliner equipped with noise-controlling devices, called chevrons, contains elements designed 15 years ago.

"This work is computationally and intellectually demanding," said Sanjiva Lele, a professor of mechanical engineering at Stanford University who is familiar with the research. "But if systematic methods to reduce noise can be found, the benefit to the aviation community would be tremendous."

Editor's Note: This research was supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF), the federal agency charged with funding basic research and education across all fields of science and engineering. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation. See the Behind the Scenes Archive.