Skip to main content

A flu shot won't prevent coronavirus, but it could help our response to the outbreak

A flu shot.
(Image: © Shutterstock)

Could the flu vaccine combat the coronavirus? That's the question President Donald Trump asked during a White house roundtable discussion between his coronavirus task force and pharmaceutical company executives on Monday (March 2).

His question was answered with a direct "no" from an executive. The flu vaccine is designed to prevent infections with influenza viruses, which are very different than coronaviruses. But the answer is slightly more complicated than that: The flu vaccine won't prevent you from getting a coronavirus, but it can help officials better respond to the outbreak of COVID-19, the disease caused by the new virus.

"I do think immunizing people against influenza has a very important indirect effect," said Dr. Albert Ko, a professor and department chair at the Yale School of Public Health. 

First, health care workers are already burdened by flu cases so getting a flu shot, reduces the number of flu patients, thereby helping to "relieve pressures" in hospitals also treating patients with COVID-19, he said.

Related: 12 Coronavirus myths busted by science

But there's another reason a flu shot could improve the country's response to the new outbreak: the U.S. is lagging behind other countries in testing for COVID-19. And that's unlikely to improve in the near term. On Thursday (March 5), Vice President Mike Pence, who is leading the administration's response to the coronavirus, announced that the U.S. does not have enough test kits to meet demand.

How does that relate to the flu? If people get their flu shots, fewer people come down with the flu and come into clinics with nonspecific symptoms such as fever and cough, which overlap with symptoms of COVID-19.

Having fewer flu patients will make it easier to find the patients with COVID-19, he said.

Higher vaccination rates would "make us much more efficient in detecting coronavirus," cases, Ko told Live Science. Finding COVID-19 cases is still akin to picking a "needle out of a haystack," but reducing flu cases can "decrease the haystack," he added. 

As SARS-CoV-2 is spreading in communities on both coasts of the U.S., distinguishing between flu and COVID-19 will become more difficult.

On the bright side, it is "incredibly rare," to catch both the flu and COVID-19 at once, said Dr. Eric Cioe Peña, director of Global Health, Northwell Health in New York and an emergency room physician. "Usually if they have one, they don't have the other."

Flu season is naturally dying down as spring approaches, but for those who haven't yet done so,  "we still recommend getting a flu shot," he added. 

People with the flu are still coming into the hospital and there's always a chance there could be a second spike of the flu, Peña told Live Science.

That being said, flu cases in New York City have been down 25% each week for the past two weeks, he said. It's a positive step "that we aren't seeing as many flu patients in the ER, so we have more room for severe coronavirus patients," Peña said. 

At Northwell Health, patients aren't being tested for COVID-19 unless they meet criteria for admission to the hospital. "That’s the only time that we're really testing because of the limited supply of tests," he added.

Originally published on Live Science.

OFFER: Save at least 53% with our latest magazine deal!

With impressive cutaway illustrations that show how things function, and mindblowing photography of the world’s most inspiring spectacles, How It Works represents the pinnacle of engaging, factual fun for a mainstream audience keen to keep up with the latest tech and the most impressive phenomena on the planet and beyond. Written and presented in a style that makes even the most complex subjects interesting and easy to understand, How It Works is enjoyed by readers of all ages.
View Deal

  • Bixbyte
    The Flu season is over perhaps that is the reason the Flu is down 25% in NY?
    Reply
  • md_dalton
    Writer needs to answer the question the headline teases sooner.
    Reply
  • Bixbyte
    The Flu Vaccine's most common side effect are Flu Like Symptoms. Do we need patients with Flu Like Symptoms to require medical attention during the end of the Flu Season?
    Would not it be better to spend our resources on prevention during the COVID-19 event?
    In My Opinion.
    Reply
  • iamsupasyfy
    Bixbyte said:
    The Flu season is over perhaps that is the reason the Flu is down 25% in NY?
    You know how to read! That's exactly what it said.
    Reply
  • iamsupasyfy
    md_dalton said:
    Writer needs to answer the question the headline teases sooner.
    um they did.........
    Reply
  • Sleet
    Honestly, this is an irresponsible headline that seemingly gives validity to one of the most inane questions asked by an idiot President. Most people don't read articles, just headlines, so this will just validate to them how intelligent their President actually is while ignoring how scientifically uninformed the question was.

    Also, as someone else pointed out, and as anyone who has gotten a flu shot knows, flu-like symptoms are a common side effect of the vaccine as your body builds immunity. Do we really want more people to have those symptoms, possibly rushing for care or testing or even masking and actual COVID-19 infection?

    I usually love this site. Today I'm very disappointed.
    Reply
  • Sleet
    Bixbyte said:
    The Flu Vaccine's most common side effect are Flu Like Symptoms. Do we need patients with Flu Like Symptoms to require medical attention during the end of the Flu Season?
    Would not it be better to spend our resources on prevention during the COVID-19 event?
    In My Opinion.
    An intelligent opinion, better thought out than the whole of this article.
    Reply
  • CFB
    Bixbyte said:
    The Flu season is over perhaps that is the reason the Flu is down 25% in NY?

    The flu season extends into May.
    Reply
  • WalterRetlaw
    If you did get a flu shot but still end up catching the flu anyway, you might not actually have the flu. You might have this SARS 2 thing that seems to be going around.
    Reply
  • CFB
    Bixbyte said:
    The Flu Vaccine's most common side effect are Flu Like Symptoms. Do we need patients with Flu Like Symptoms to require medical attention during the end of the Flu Season?
    Would not it be better to spend our resources on prevention during the COVID-19 event?
    In My Opinion.

    The flu shots common side effects do not include flu like symptoms. If you think it does, you haven't had the flu in a long time. In the vast majority of cases, some redness/soreness at the site of injection, a very mild fever and not much else is what you would feel. Someone with the full blown flu would have respiratory distress, serious body aches, mucus out the wazoo, and not at all look like someone "suffering from flu-like symptoms from a flu shot".
    Reply