'We just had no answers': COVID-19 'long-haulers' still learning why they're sick
Recurrent fevers, persistent constipation or diarrhea, intense bouts of fatigue, debilitating brain fog and vivid hallucinations — some people who catch COVID-19 experience symptoms like these for months on end, and we're still learning why that is.
Data gathered early in the pandemic suggested that most people with COVID-19 recover within a few weeks, if they survive the illness. But around April, stories began surfacing from those who remained sick for months after their initial symptoms emerged. Many of these individuals came together online to form support groups, with some referring to themselves "COVID long-haulers."
Now, six months since the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 a pandemic, formal studies of long-haulers are only just getting off the ground. But patients aren't waiting for science to catch up; they are organizing to collect data on their symptoms, tie those symptoms to biological explanations, and even to share potential — and unapproved — treatments. Knowing whether any of those treatments can alleviate the long-lasting symptoms of COVID-19, however, will take a more systematic approach and clinical trials, experts told Live Science.
Related: 20 of the worst epidemics and pandemics in history
A wide array of symptoms
One of the biggest ways long-haulers have expanded knowledge of the condition is by thoroughly cataloguing their symptoms. A patient-led research group, born out of the Body Politic COVID-19 Support Group, published the results of a survey of long-haulers in May that detailed some of their most common symptoms.
"At the time, we just had no answers," said Hannah Davis, a composer, independent researcher and core member of the Patient-Led Research for COVID-19 team. Davis began experiencing symptoms of COVID-19 on March 25, and to this day, many of her primary symptoms are neurological, she said.
"My first symptom was that I couldn't read a text message," Davis told Live Science, and she said her most persistent symptom has been "brain fog," or general cognitive dysfunction and trouble concentrating. In the May survey, nearly 70% of the 640 respondents reported experiencing either brain fog, insomnia or concentration issues, making these symptoms as common as a cough among long-haulers. A smaller percentage reported memory loss, dizziness, involuntary tremors, numbness in their extremities or hallucinations.
It's unknown whether neurological symptoms like these mostly arise from increased inflammation in the body or from the coronavirus directly infecting brain cells, though there's evidence for both, Live Science previously reported.
Related: What are the symptoms of COVID-19?
In addition to brain fog, many of the survey participants reported shortness of breath, tightness in the chest, fatigue, chills, body aches and a slightly elevated temperature, between 98.8 degrees Fahrenheit (37.1 degrees Celsius) and 100 F (37.7 C). Some less common symptoms included high fevers and severe gastrointestinal issues, such as constipation lasting for weeks, bowel obstructions and diarrhea leading to rapid weight loss. Long-haulers also reported seizures, migraines, vision changes, sensitivity to light and phantom smells, or smelling things that aren't there.
"For me, I've definitely experienced at least 100 symptoms over the last five months," Davis said. "People call it a 'grab bag,'" because some symptoms persist for many months while others seem to randomly crop up then disappear, she said. For instance, while brain fog remains her main symptom, Davis said she had transient rib pain, phantom smells and even vivid hallucinations that lasted a day or two, then went away.
"Long COVID is a whole spectrum of different conditions," said Paul Garner, a professor at the School of Tropical Medicine in Liverpool, England, who also developed his initial COVID-19 symptoms in March. But one common refrain is a sense of overwhelming fatigue.
Garner is among long-haulers who experience such fatigue as one of their main symptoms; some have compared the condition to myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), the exact cause of which is unknown.
When dealing with a new chronic illness, it's difficult to know what activities will trigger symptoms, Garner said. "You don’t know the speed limit and you don’t know when the penalties will arrive. You find out that when they do they are harsh, stopping you in your tracks for days," he wrote in a blog post published in June in The British Medical Journal Opinion.
He said he's learned that ample rest and keeping a decent diet helps keep his symptoms at bay, while physical activity and consuming alcohol can set them off. Similarly, 89% of respondents to the patient-led survey reported experiencing relapses in their symptoms, sometimes set off by exercise, stress, caffeine, alcohol or heat.
Related: 25 medical myths that just won't go away
In the case of the fatigue she's experienced after contracting COVID-19, the sensation doesn't set in like typical tiredness, which comes on gradually, Dr. Mady Hornig, a physician-scientist at the Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, told Live Science. "From my own experience, it's more like you're an electrical device and every once in a while someone pulls out the plug," she said. Hornig developed symptoms of COVID-19, including a fever and cough, back in April. Now, "I've had to be on a toddler's time table with self-enforced rest," she said.
But could a COVID-19 infection really trigger the onset of ME/CFS? Hornig said it's possible, given that other viral infections have been linked to the syndrome. For instance, an estimated 10% to 12% of people with infectious mono, caused by the Epstein-Barr virus, later develop a chronic course of ME/CFS, she said. (This increased risk is associated with symptomatic mono, according to a commentary in The Journal of Infectious Disease; most people carry the Epstein-Barr virus without developing any symptoms of illness.) Hornig said that she expects that, similarly, a percentage of patients who catch COVID-19 may go on to develop ME/CFS.
Hornig is now leading a study of "post-COVID phenomena" at Columbia to determine whether and how many long-haulers develop ME/CFS, as well as what other conditions crop up after the initial infection subsides. She also wants to track whether any long-haulers eventually stop experiencing symptoms; blood or tissue samples from these people could hint at what helps the body "bounce back" after prolonged illness, she said.
One of the major challenges in devising such studies is deciding what "post-COVID" really means, Hornig noted. "What is post-COVID? … The before and after becomes very blurry," she said. The acute, or short-term, phase of an infection is typically defined by characteristic symptoms that appear in a particular order, she said. But with COVID-19 patients, the initial symptoms vary person to person, and some people don't experience any overt symptoms, like cough or fever, but still go on to develop signs of organ damage.
"We still have much to learn about the variations in the onset, symptoms, signs and time to resolution of the acute disease, let alone what clinical symptoms or biomarkers might help predict long-term persistence of illness," Hornig said.
Hornig's research group is collaborating with the ME/CFS focused nonprofit Solve ME to develop a symptom tracking app for long-haulers, with the goal of tracking their symptoms over time and matching them up with patients' verifiable medical records. They are using data from long-hauler surveys, including ones conducted by the advocacy group Survivor Corps, to craft their survey questions. The medical records help confirm that when a patient reports experiencing brain inflammation, for example, brain scans back that up.
Dealing with doctors
The Patient-Led Research group is also launching a new project in conjunction with University College London. Their second survey will cover the first seven months of symptoms and ask about antibody test results, as some long-haulers don't test positive for antibodies when assessed, Davis said. This can become a sticking point when long-haulers seek medical care for their symptoms, because many never had a diagnostic test for COVID-19 when they first fell ill, she added. Therefore, antibodies would provide the only medical proof that they caught the virus at all.
In the U.S. "in March, April, you were only able to get a test if you were hospitalized. And most long-haulers are not hospitalized," Davis said. Even when long-haulers could get a diagnostic test, some got tested too late in the course of their illness, she said.
To account for that, the first patient-led survey included all symptomatic people, regardless of whether they had a positive COVID-19 diagnostic test or not. And their results indirectly support the notion that long-haulers without a positive test likely had COVID-19.The main difference between people who tested positive and those who tested negative was when they received their test. On average, positive people got tested on day 10 after developing symptoms, while negative people got tested on day 16. The diagnostic tests work by detecting bits of viral genetic material, and are more likely to give false-negatives once the body has had time to fight off the infection and the amount of virus in their body decreases, Live Science previously reported.
Related: 14 coronavirus myths busted by science
Requiring a positive diagnostic or antibody test poses a problem for many people seeking treatment for long-COVID. "Many post-COVID clinics require positive tests to be admitted," Davis said. "Diagnostic tests need to be deprioritized … Clinical diagnoses have to be enough," meaning long-haulers should be admitted based on what symptoms they show, she said.
She noted that, because long-haulers experience such a wide range of symptoms, patients should also receive a "full workup" of medical screenings, from pulmonary to cardiovascular to neurological.
Long-haulers all over the world have shared stories of doctors not believing that they had had COVID-19, and brushing off their symptoms as psychiatric in origin, Garner noted. "People were going in and being diagnosed with anxiety; it was appalling," he said. Hornig, a physician and psychiatrist herself, also encountered doubt from her health care providers when she tested negative for COVID-19 and for antibodies against the virus, she told Stat News in August. But she also tested negative for 12 other respiratory pathogens, including influenza, and based on her symptoms and the course of her disease, COVID-19 was the best explanation for why she fell ill, she said.
When seeing a doctor about persistent COVID-19 symptoms it may help to come prepared with documents describing your medical history, timeline of COVID-19 symptoms and the top questions you have for them, JD Davids, a writer, strategist and contributor to the Patient-Led Research survey, told Live Science in an email. It also helps to understand the medical practice inside and out, such as how long you might wait to see a specialist and who to call with insurance problems, he said.
Promising treatments, potential pitfalls
As a long-time advocate for people with chronic health conditions like HIV/AIDS and ME/CFS, Davids said that the lack of support long-haulers face reflects a historic trend in how health care providers treat those with chronic conditions. That's why patient-led groups play such a vital role in gathering information about their disease and potential treatment options, he said. Earlier in the year, Davids helped organize a webinar for people already living with chronic illness called "COVID-19 (Coronavirus) Preparation for People Living with Chronic Illnesses in the U.S.," to provide guidance for those who might face a heightened risk of severe disease, prolonged symptoms or death from COVID-19.
"These social networks are very fast at learning … medical science communicates through long, rather boring papers that take months of preparation," Garner said.
The speed of information spread in social networks can also mean speculative or untested treatments become widely known very quickly. For instance, some long-haulers say they have benefited from taking the heartburn medication famotidine, better known by the brand name Pepcid, Davis said. Specifically, they say the drug seems to ease their shortness of breath and reduce brain fog.
Related: Treatments for COVID-19: Drugs being tested against the coronavirus
Famotidine is a histamine 2 (H2) blocker, meaning it works by blocking receptors for the compound histamine, one of several substances that trigger stomach acid production. Beyond the stomach, histamine also helps kick the immune system into gear when it detects a pathogen, according to a commentary published in In The Pipeline, a blog curated by the journal Science Translational Medicine. However, this short-term immune response becomes overblown in some COVID-19 patients, which could explain why famotidine appears to help some long-haulers, the commentary notes.
Other long-haulers in the Body Politic COVID-19 Support Group have said they found benefit from acupuncture, compression stockings and lymphatic massage, and some with primarily cardiovascular symptoms take salt tablets. COVID-19 may sometimes be linked to dysfunction of the autonomic nervous system, which controls involuntary functions like breathing and heart rate, according to a case report in The American Journal of the Medical Sciences; salt tablets may be used to treat the blood circulation problems and rapid heart rate that can arise from such disorders, according to the Cleveland Clinic.
But when it comes to these remedies for long-COVID symptoms, "there is no evidence that these different treatments have benefits for a large number of patients," said Dr. Michael Matthay, a professor of medicine at University of California, San Francisco School of Medicine. "However, they may have value for individual patients." In other words, if individual patients find a mild treatment like famotidine or massage helpful, then it's reasonable for them to consider that treatment as long it does not cause significant side effects, he said. Above all, people who continue to feel ill for months after their initial COVID-19 infection should be closely monitored by health care providers, in order to pinpoint the source of their prolonged symptoms and find solutions, Matthay added.
In the end, clinical trials will be needed to determine if any of these treatments actually work, and if so, how they work to alleviate specific symptoms.
As all that work gets underway, Davis said that doctors can start helping long-haulers by doing one simple thing:
"The easiest and first thing doctors can do is say 'I believe you,'" she said.
Editor's note: This story was updated on September 18, 12:15 p.m. EDT to correct the description of the webinar organized by JD Davids. The original story was published at 7 a.m. EDT the same day.
Originally published on Live Science.
Live Science newsletter
Stay up to date on the latest science news by signing up for our Essentials newsletter.
Nicoletta Lanese is the health channel editor at Live Science and was previously a news editor and staff writer at the site. She holds a graduate certificate in science communication from UC Santa Cruz and degrees in neuroscience and dance from the University of Florida. Her work has appeared in The Scientist, Science News, the Mercury News, Mongabay and Stanford Medicine Magazine, among other outlets. Based in NYC, she also remains heavily involved in dance and performs in local choreographers' work.
By Briley Lewis
By Harry Baker
However, this persistent, low level viral production seen in some people is similar to what is seen in a primary natural reservoir for coronaviruses, which are bats. They too seems to have low levels of persistent cornavirus production, which does not cause them any apparent harm. But then they would likely have evolved with these "parasitic" infections and have managed to avoid long term health problems. That is why viral "isolates" from bats, and other animals, are suspect in the current pandemic. Of course, humans might not be prepared for this type of viral infection. It remains to be seen,.
Clearance of the virus without ill-effect seems not to be the case in many people, like the "long-haulers' in the above story. Some have been re-assayed for the virus, and it comes back negative. But how close are they looking it? The extent of symptoms strongly suggest this virus is much more than a respiratory threat. It appears to be a threat to nearly every organ and tissue in the body. A good reason for this is its interaction with the receptor(s) involved in neurological functions. and some suspect the ACE* complex as a primary target. These receptors are found on many cells all over the body, but particularly those of the neurological system. The bizarre behavior of brain fog and worse conditions like hallucinations might indicate that a low level of circulating active virions are causing such symptoms, and not everyone is prone to it (yet).
For anyone suffering from these problems, it would be highly advisable to determine if you have retained active production of the virus at low levels, as described above. Such a test would require more work up than the standard genome assay. Careful sample handling and greater amplification of long-hauler blood/tissue samples might provide a clue about the nature of their problems.
Continuous low level virus production could certainly cause damage to many organs if they infect them and cause significant cell death, and localized amplification of the virus. The immune system would like tamp down such an outbreak rather quickly, but if persistent viral production is the cause of extended problems post-infection, additional therapies like antivirals may be required, in addition to boosting immune function, if possible. Some of the soon to be approved (we hope) vaccines might help alleviate symptoms if low-level virus production is involved. They may provide a unique response to suppress viral levels even more.