When it comes to so-called good cholesterol, a new study suggests there could be truth to the phrase "too much of a good thing."
The study, from a team of researchers in Atlanta, found that, in people with cardiovascular disease, very high levels of "good" cholesterol, or high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol, are associated with a considerably higher risk of heart attack and death from cardiovascular causes. In fact, the scientists found that people with very high levels of HDL cholesterol in their blood have as high a risk of heart attack and death from cardiovascular disease as those with very low levels.
The findings were presented Aug. 25 at the European Society of Cardiology Congress 2018 in Vienna, and the study authors discussed their work at a news conference Aug. 27. The findings have not yet been published in a peer-reviewed journal. [9 New Ways to Keep Your Heart Healthy]
HDL cholesterol has long been hailed for its positive qualities in the body, including its ability to clean arteries and its association with a lower risk of cardiovascular disease.
"The HDL molecule is very complex and does a lot of things in the body," said lead study author Dr. Marc Allard-Ratick, an internal-medicine resident at the Emory University School of Medicine in Atlanta. "One of the things that it does is that it helps to move bad cholesterol away from the blood vessel wall and out of the body."
What's more, "many studies have shown an inverse association between the good cholesterol and adverse cardiovascular events like heart attack," Allard-Ratick said. Most of those earlier studies, however, didn't look at patients with very high levels of HDL in their blood, he said.
So, in the study, the researchers enrolled nearly 6,000 patients who had already been diagnosed with cardiovascular disease or had a high probability of having cardiovascular disease. The researchers measured the patients' HDL levels, and collected data about their medical history and background.
The patients were divided into five groups, based on their blood HDL cholesterol levels: Less than 30 milligrams per deciliter (mg/dL), 31-40 mg/dL, 41-50 mg/dL, 51-60 mg/dL and more than 60 mg/dL. (HDL cholesterol levels above 60 mg/dL are considered "optimal," according to the Mayo Clinic.)
Then, the researchers tracked the patients for approximately four years. During the follow-up period, 769 patients either died of cardiovascular-related causes or had a heart attack.
The study found that both the patients with the highest level and the lowest HDL cholesterol level had the highest probability of dying from cardiovascular disease or experiencing a heart attack, Allard-Ratick told Live Science.
Specifically, patients with HDL cholesterol levels above 60 mg/dL had a 50 percent greater risk of a heart attack or dying from cardiovascular disease, compared with those with HDL cholesterol levels between 41 and 60 mg/dL. And this increase was about the same as the risk of those with HDL cholesterol levels below 41 mg/dL, the researchers found.
But it's unclear why the very high levels of HDL cholesterol were associated with such negative effects, the researchers said.
Dr. Heinz Drexel, a cardiologist at the State Hospital Feldkirch in Austria who was not involved in the study, said that very high levels of HDL cholesterol are much less common in patients with cardiovascular disease. Rather, these patients are much more likely to have low levels of HDL cholesterol, he said.
"We see very high levels of HDL, over 80mg[/dL], in only about 1 percent of the patient population," Drexel told Live Science. "On the other hand, we see low levels below 40mg[/dL] in about half of the patients."
Still, Drexel said that the study is significant, as it's the first one to look at very high HDL cholesterol levels in people with cardiovascular disease.
"We have known for decades that low HDL cholesterol [puts people at risk of] developing cardiovascular disease," Drexel said.“What is new is that the very high levels are also not so good, so we can't say that this good cholesterol, this HDL cholesterol, is simply always good."
Allard-Ratick said that the very high levels of HDL cholesterol observed in the study are more likely a result of genetics than of lifestyle choices. Indeed, Allard-Rattick and Drexel said that at very high levels, the HDL molecules might not be performing their functions efficiently, resulting in a build-up of cholesterol in the blood. However, both agreed that more research is needed to understand the risks as well as the underlying mechanisms.
Originally published on Live Science.
Sign up for the Live Science daily newsletter now
Get the world’s most fascinating discoveries delivered straight to your inbox.