Social Networking Sites May Foster Same Old Divisions

Photo taken by Simon Cataudo. (scataudo) There are no usage restrictions for this photo

The social networking site of choice is related to a student's race, ethnicity and parents' education, a new survey indicates.

The finding "suggests there's less intermingling of users from varying backgrounds on these sites than previously believed," said study leader Eszter Hargittai of the Institute for Policy Research at Northwestern University in Illinois.

Hargittai surveyed more than 1,000 freshmen from the University of Illinois, Chicago.

Results show:

  • Caucasian students prefer Facebook.
  • Hispanic students prefer MySpace.
  • Asian and Asian-American students were more likely than others to "socialize" on Xanga and Friendster. They also used Facebook.
  • Asian and Asian-American students are least likely to use MySpace.

Parents' education level was also found to impact choice of social networking site. Students whose parents had college degrees more often reported Facebook and Xanga use compared with students with non-college-degree parents. (Facebook required a valid college e-mail ID when it was first launched, but has since removed such requirements.)

MySpace users were skewed toward students with parents having less than a high-school education than those with even some college experience (with or without achieving a college degree).

In some ways, the results suggest that rather than bringing all walks of life onto a level playing field, the Internet's social networking sites might just be fostering more of the same barriers found in real life.

For instance, college students living with their parents (and are already less connected with other students) were less likely to use Facebook than their on-campus peers.

"Everyone points to that wonderful New Yorker cartoon of the dog at the computer telling a canine friend by his side that 'on the Internet nobody knows you're a dog,'" Hargittai said. "In reality, however, it appears that online actions and interactions should not be viewed as independent of one’s offline identity."

Overall, 80 percent of students reported using Facebook, with 75 percent of students reporting frequent use. MySpace was used by 54 percent of students, with nearly 40 percent reporting frequent use. Less than 1 percent of students indicated using other sites (in order of relative ranking): Xanga, Friendster, Orkut and Bebo.

The study is published in the Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication.

Live Science Staff
For the science geek in everyone, Live Science offers a fascinating window into the natural and technological world, delivering comprehensive and compelling news and analysis on everything from dinosaur discoveries, archaeological finds and amazing animals to health, innovation and wearable technology. We aim to empower and inspire our readers with the tools needed to understand the world and appreciate its everyday awe.