Why hasn't ET phoned Earth? Maybe aliens are waiting for the exact right moment.

An artist's illustration of a rocky, Earth-like exoplanet (in this case, Kepler-1649c), orbiting its sun. Aliens on such a planet might choose to beam signals toward Earth when they are directly between Earth and their own sun.
An artist's illustration of a rocky, Earth-like exoplanet (in this case, Kepler-1649c), orbiting its sun. Aliens on such a planet might choose to beam signals toward Earth when they are directly between Earth and their own sun. (Image credit: NASA/Ames Research Center/Daniel Rutter)

Aliens may be waiting until a cosmic version of "high noon" to send out their signals to us, scientists have suggested. 

In a new study, researchers hunted for technological signs of E.T. during the moments when exoplanets pass directly in front of their suns, from Earth's point of view. These exact moments could be the perfect chance for an alien world to beam out a signal to Earthlings in an attempt to make contact. 

"Exoplanetary transits are special because they can be calculated by both us on Earth, as the observers, and also any potential technological species in the exoplanetary system itself, as the transmitters," said study leader Sofia Sheikh (opens in new tab), a postdoctoral researcher in radio astronomy at the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) Institute. These transits, then, are a predictable and repetitive time during which aliens might think to send messages and Earthlings might look to receive them. 

"This strategy helps us narrow down the huge question of where and when to look for a message in the vast reaches of space," Sheikh told Live Science in an email. 

The new study, published Dec. 9 on the preprint site arXiv (opens in new tab) and scheduled for peer-reviewed publication in The Astronomical Journal, did not find any evidence of chatty aliens. But the study only searched a dozen far-off planets. In the future, they plan to look further with a variety of telescopes. 

Related: Is it time to send another message to intelligent aliens? Some scientists think so.

Since radio technology was invented in the late 19th century, Earth has been leaking transmissions into space — and occasionally, as with the famed Arecibo Message of 1974, has sent them out deliberately in hopes of contacting any intelligent extraterrestrial that might be listening. Hoping that intelligent alien civilizations might also leak out technological signals, or technosignals, researchers also scan the galaxy for radio waves that might have originated from alien tech. 

But the galaxy is a big place, so a key question is where to look. Sheikh and her team settled on eavesdropping on far-off exoplanets as they pass in front of their suns, in what is known as a "Schelling point" — a solution to a problem that two individuals tend to default to if they aren't communicating with one another. In other words, the moment of planetary transit just seems the logical moment to connect from the point of view of both the transmitter and receiver. 

Sheikh and her colleagues used West Virginia's Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope to search for radio signals from 12 exoplanets whose transits were observable during a brief window in March 2018. They detected plenty of radio signals — almost 34,000, in fact — but 99.6% of those could be dismissed out of hand as interference from Earthbound communications. A group of trained citizen scientists did the work of examining the signals. 

In the end, all but two of the signals were determined to be due to interference. The remaining two, a couple of short bursts from Kepler-1332b and Kepler-842b — both potentially rocky planets larger than Earth — were deemed worthy of further follow-up. However, Sheikh said, those two are also almost certainly due to interference and are not real messages. 

Nevertheless, she said, the study was proof that the search method can work. The researchers plan to tackle more observations in the future at the SETI Institute's Allen Telescope Array in California. 

Stephanie Pappas
Live Science Contributor

Stephanie Pappas is a contributing writer for Live Science, covering topics ranging from geoscience to archaeology to the human brain and behavior. She was previously a senior writer for Live Science but is now a freelancer based in Denver, Colorado, and regularly contributes to Scientific American and The Monitor, the monthly magazine of the American Psychological Association. Stephanie received a bachelor's degree in psychology from the University of South Carolina and a graduate certificate in science communication from the University of California, Santa Cruz. 

  • Snorrie
    Perhaps "ET" is/has been already here on Earth inside our brains as constructs of religious beliefs, superstitions, "gut feelings", ghosts, memories, etc. I.E.: Randomly placed there by Evolution as a survival mechanism. Could it be that looking for "ET" is as simple as looking in a mirror. As least the distance would not be as far as the stars and "traversed" much quicker than requiring the speed of light. ....... Of course, government and private funding for "ET in the Stars" has unanticipated benefits; no complaint there.
    Reply
  • Rachann
    Perhaps we are the Sentinelese islanders of our solar neighbourhood. Considered to violent to approach or contact.
    Reply
  • bolide2
    Looking for the "exact right moment" to send or receive, just when the exoplanet is transiting--are they taking into account how far away that planet is, and how long it would take a signal to cover the distance, and where, in its orbit, the planet will be, when the signal actually gets there?
    Reply
  • Ocyrus
    Also, wouldn't the residents of such a planet need to know where we are in order to calculate that point in their orbit? And by extension, wouldn't they have to be intentionally trying to communicate with us specifically, as opposed to "searching" for someone capable of receiving their message? I suppose they could be continuously broadcasting in the direction facing away from their star. But to have that capability would require a huge amount of communication equipment, not to mention continuous power to said global network. If their society is similar to our own, they may face the same setbacks we on earth have to contend with. And as we know from our own history, humans can't get along with each other long enough to make a concerted effort toward any common goal, let alone such a huge undertaking as an interstellar communications network. Not to say it isn't possible. Especially for a race older than humanity. But then again, who's to say that even a more advanced civilization than ours are really that much different than us? Then again, most of our outbound signals have been entertainment related. Maybe they know exactly where we are, but the crap we're sending out isn't worth their effort to answer us.
    Reply
  • Snorrie
    In my overly cynical opinion, ET just doesn't exist either due to the extreme distances and the expansion of space or most likely, evolutionary reality. Basically, IMO, ET is a chimera of our primate brains for a "Deus Ex Machina" hopefully leading us into a better "utopian world". Sadly, we, nasty, little, carnivore, tribal apes with nuclear weapons need all the hope we can muster to blunt the self-inflicted grim realities of our existence.
    Reply