Neanderthals passed down their tall noses to modern humans, genetic analysis finds

Two skulls showing a comparison of nasal cavities.
A comparison of a modern human skull (left) and a Neanderthal skull, showing the difference in nasal cavity height. (Image credit: Kaustubh Adhikari)

Neanderthals were equipped with tall noses that could warm and moisten the cold and dry air around them in chilly climates — an adaptation that may be the result of natural selection.

These sizable schnozzes were likely helpful to Neanderthals; once anatomically modern humans (Homo sapiens) left Africa and joined Neanderthals up north in Eurasia, the two mated, with Neanderthals gifting Homo sapiens their bigger-nose genes, a new study finds.

Scientists made the discovery after analyzing DNA taken from more than 6,000 volunteers recruited from Brazil, Colombia, Chile, Mexico and Peru who had Latin American, mixed European, Native American or African heritage, and compared their genetic information to photographs of their faces, according to a study published May 8 in the journal Communications Biology.

After measuring the distances between different points on each face, such as the height of a person's nose, the researchers compared those data to see if those characteristics were associated with certain genetic markers, according to a statement.

The researchers successfully identified 33 new genome regions that corresponded with facial features. One in particular, ATF3, not only had Neanderthal origins but also defined nose height. They found that study participants with Native American ancestry "had genetic material in this gene that was inherited from the Neanderthals, contributing to increased nasal height," according to the statement.

Related: Human and Neanderthal brains have a surprising 'youthful' quality in common, new research finds

"It has long been speculated that the shape of our noses is determined by natural selection; as our noses can help us to regulate the temperature and humidity of the air we breathe in, different shaped noses may be better suited to different climates that our ancestors lived in," lead author Qing Li, a faculty member in the Department of Environmental Science and Engineering at Fudan University in Shanghai, said in the statement. "The gene we have identified here may have been inherited from Neanderthals to help humans adapt to colder climates as our ancestors moved out of Africa."

In 2021, the same team of researchers conducted a related study that identified a gene that influenced lip shape. That gene, called TBX15, was inherited from the Denisovans, modern-human relatives who lived in Asia and went extinct approximately 30,000 years ago. The Denisovans interbred with Homo sapiens, passing along this genetic attribute. By examining data from this previous study, the researchers discovered that, like Native Americans, East Asians were also more likely to have the ATF3 nose gene.

So what was the benefit of having a taller nose thousands of years ago? 

"When you live in colder climates, your nose gets narrower so that it can warm cold air before it reaches the lungs," study co-author Kaustubh Adhikari, a statistical geneticist at University College London, told Live Science. "We think that when [Homo sapiens] came into colder regions where Neanderthals were already living, they bred with them and they passed along these [genetic] benefits to their children, which helped give them a leg up with adaptation." 

Jennifer Nalewicki
Live Science Staff Writer

Jennifer Nalewicki is a Salt Lake City-based journalist whose work has been featured in The New York Times, Smithsonian Magazine, Scientific American, Popular Mechanics and more. She covers several science topics from planet Earth to paleontology and archaeology to health and culture. Prior to freelancing, Jennifer held an Editor role at Time Inc. Jennifer has a bachelor's degree in Journalism from The University of Texas at Austin.

  • bgaineshunter1
    Which humans are we talking about? Neanderthals are not known to have lived in Africa. I supposed if you have European or Asian DNA you could have inherited your "tall" from the Neanderthals.
    Reply
  • MaxEisen
    admin said:
    A new genetic analysis found that the of Neanderthal noses was passed down to modern humans.

    Neanderthals passed down their tall noses to modern humans, genetic analysis finds : Read more
    The article bases this on genetic markers that indicate when we "adapted to colder climates". Humans have STILL NOT adapted to the cold. We have ZERO defenses for the cold. What adaptation? If we lost all our fur (our only real protection), what did we gain in "evolution" that "adapted" us to colder climates.
    Reply
  • bgaineshunter1
    MaxEisen said:
    The article bases this on genetic markers that indicate when we "adapted to colder climates". Humans have STILL NOT adapted to the cold. We have ZERO defenses for the cold. What adaptation? If we lost all our fur (our only real protection), what did we gain in "evolution" that "adapted" us to colder climates.
    I understand that, but the article makes it sound as if all populations of humans inherited that trait. Since Neanderthals did not live within Africa, Africans did not.
    Reply
  • MaxEisen
    bgaineshunter1 said:
    I understand that, but the article makes it sound as if all populations of humans inherited that trait. Since Neanderthals did not live within Africa, Africans did not.
    I agree with you. I'm saying the article just made this entire thing up and their basis is rooted in something that never actually happened. Humans have NEVER adapted to cold climates. That's why I challenge them to name the other evolutionary traits we developed to protect us from the cold. They literally just made this up to promote the conversation that the life that started in Africa was idle until Africans became Europeans/White. Lol we DONT have a SINGLE defense against cold weather. Not one.
    Reply
  • bgaineshunter1
    MaxEisen said:
    I agree with you. I'm saying the article just made this entire thing up and their basis is rooted in something that never actually happened. Humans have NEVER adapted to cold climates. That's why I challenge them to name the other evolutionary traits we developed to protect us from the cold. They literally just made this up to promote the conversation that the life that started in Africa was idle until Africans became Europeans/White. Lol we DONT have a SINGLE defense against cold weather. Not one.
    What makes you think that humans have never adapted to cold climates? Most of Europe is cold, and humans have lived there for tens of thousands of years. People living in Eurooe slaughtered animals for their fur, something that Africans did not need to do. A lot of European adaptions, including their appearance was for survival in cold, forested climates. People who have blue eyes, for instance, actually do see better in the dark.

    The brown skin of most Africans is 'camouflage' in African environments. The lighter skin of Europeans is 'camouflage' in colder environments. The darker skin of most Africans is an adaption to hair loss and heat. The skin color offers some protection against the equatorial sun. The lighter skin of European makes it easier for them to absorb vitamin D from sunlight. Europe has less sunlight than Africa. Studies show that it take about 10,000 years, plus the right amounts of vitamin D and folic acid to go from dark skin to light skin.

    Although I know that racism is alive and well (I especially think that biological theories are often off), I am not willing to throw the baby out with the bathwater. Many of my fellow African Americans sound like Trump, although Trump is more mean-spirited than just ignorant.
    Reply
  • Leynir
    bgaineshunter1 said:
    What makes you think that humans have never adapted to cold climates? Most of Europe is cold, and humans have lived there for tens of thousands of years. People living in Eurooe slaughtered animals for their fur, something that Africans did not need to do. A lot of European adaptions, including their appearance was for survival in cold, forested climates. People who have blue eyes, for instance, actually do see better in the dark.

    The brown skin of most Africans is 'camouflage' in African environments. The lighter skin of Europeans is 'camouflage' in colder environments. The darker skin of most Africans is an adaption to hair loss and heat. The skin color offers some protection against the equatorial sun. The lighter skin of European makes it easier for them to absorb vitamin D from sunlight. Europe has less sunlight than Africa. Studies show that it take about 10,000 years, plus the right amounts of vitamin D and folic acid to go from dark skin to light skin.

    Although I know that racism is alive and well (I especially think that biological theories are often off), I am not willing to throw the baby out with the bathwater. Many of my fellow African Americans sound like Trump, although Trump is more mean-spirited than just ignorant.
    I wanted to give you a thumbs up until I got to the last paragraph.
    Reply