Expert Voices

The Threat of Illegal Fishing Is Too Great to Ignore (Op-Ed)

trawling, fishing
(Image credit: Ben Sutherland via flickr |

Michele Kuruc is the World Wildlife Fund's (WWF) acting senior vice president for marine conservation. She oversees WWF's work to build healthy and resilient marine ecosystems. She has more than two decades of experience in protecting the world's oceans and combating illegal fishing. She contributed this article to Live Science's Expert Voices: Op-Ed & Insights

Most people have watched someone play the card game three-card monte at some point in their lives. To win the bet, all the player needs to do is follow one of three cards as the dealer quickly rearranges them on a table. The player — who closely tracks his card as the shady dealer tries to confuse him about which card is which — then picks out the card he thinks is the correct one. 

It's a very simple game, but one where the dealer somehow always wins. Why? Because he uses confusion, misdirection and a little sleight of hand to conceal the true movement of the card from the person tracking it. 

While three-card monte is something you typically see late at night on city streets, it's happening every day in the planet's oceans . But there, it's not just a card game — it's an international problem called illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing. And the con men that play it are making up to $23 billion each year.

In the same way the dealer hides the movement of his cards, illegal fishermen work to hide the movement of their catch. Illegal product infiltrates the market as seafood moves among multiple fishers, processors, importers and exporters. As the cards are shuffled — as seafood is combined, shipped, processed and shipped again without consistent documentation — regulators, retailers and consumers lose the ability to differentiate legal from illegal product.

While the challenge before law enforcement is immense, the tide is beginning to turn against those profiting from illegal fishing. Government leaders, along with the fishing industry itself, now recognize the true scope and scale of illegal fishing and are actively taking steps to end it. 

Illegal fishing creates billions of dollars of illicit profits at the expense of ocean ecosystems. (Image credit: © World Wildlife Fund (WWF))

In fact, last week — in front of ocean leaders from more than 80 nations at the U.S. State Department's Our Ocean conference — U.S. President Barack Obama announced a new initiative designed to coordinate efforts among all federal agencies to close U.S. markets to illegally caught seafood. The administration recognizes that it's past time to break the unintended link between U.S. dollars and illegal fishing, and to provide security to seafood retailers and consumers.

If you're a topical expert — researcher, business leader, author or innovator — and would like to contribute an op-ed piece, email us here.

The U.S. government should use this moment to bring together the public and affected stakeholders to design smart regulations that would require bait-to-plate traceability (essentially standardized information about the who, what, where, when and how of fishing) and proof of legality as conditions of import. This transparency will open up the system and make it harder for illegal fish to mix with those responsibly sourced.

Like catching a three-card monte dealer red-handed, ending illegal fishing will not be easy. But the threat it places on marine ecosystems  and the livelihoods it supports are too great to ignore. 

Follow all of the Expert Voices issues and debates — and become part of the discussion — on FacebookTwitter and Google +. The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.  This version of the article was originally published on Live Science.

World Wildlife Fund