All that chatter this week about the Phoenix Mars lander possibly tasting perchlorates in the martian soil sent everybody to the chemistry books.
Finding perchlorates, if confirmed, is neither bad nor good for the prospect of life on Mars, according to Michael Hecht, lead scientist at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory for the Microscopy, Electrochemistry and Conductivity Analyzer — MECA for short, thank goodness — the instrument that includes a wet chemistry laboratory.
But what caught my attention is that perchlorates are an ingredient used in rocket fuel and fireworks.
Immediately, I could see future Mars adventurers saluting their own independence day from Earth by shooting off fireworks. If that’s the case, why not process the soil to make the red planet a convenient refueling spot for blasting off to other destinations?
I shot a note off to a couple of Mars futurists about using perchlorates as a resource gold mine.
Robert Zubrin, the spark plug behind the Mars Society, responded: “It conceivably could be used to create solid rocket propellants or explosives.”
But Gerald Sanders, NASA’s guru for on-the-spot resource utilization, had a different take about made-on-Mars solid rocket propellant.
“One, solid propellants are much lower performing than liquids. Two, while solid rockets are simpler than liquid systems, it is easier to fill an empty liquid tank than to cast a solid motor. Three, if I am going through the trouble to dig up and process Mars dirt, I would get the water first. Even at low water concentrations (three to eight percent), water and carbon dioxide can allow me to make oxygen, methane, or a large number of other hydrocarbon fuels.”
I also wondered like others whether perchlorate on Mars had been sprinkled in the Phoenix landing zone by all those pyros that had to fire to deploy spacecraft hardware - that the lander has detected its own detritus.
Ed Sedivy, Phoenix program manager at Lockheed Martin Space Systems Company, said that they’ve been looking into this prospect, but “can find no credible connection between the lander itself and the perchlorate detected by MECA.”
Sedivy told me that the pyros used on Phoenix are NASA Standard Initiators - a device that contains a charge that is captured (non-vented) and does contain some perchlorates (potassium, titanium, zirconium) - all of a 100 milligrams per charge.
“So our pyros are not consistent with the MECA signature, they are not vented, and the quantity of material is very small,” Sedivy said. “So at this point, I don’t see a credible connection to the spacecraft.”