Lawmakers again peppered NASA chief Michael Griffin Tuesday on whether there can be any cooperation between the space exploration efforts of the U.S. and China, prompted – no doubt – by the recent diplomatic visit of Chinese President Hu Jintao and conference appearances by high-ranking Chinese space officials.
“Where do you see us going with China?” Sen. Bill Nelson, a Democrat from Florida, asked Griffin during a Senate subcommittee hearing Tuesday. “Competitor or colleague?”
Griffin, for his part, seems open to cooperation, else he – and President George W. Bush – would not have opted to take up China’s invitation to visit the China National Space Administration facilities during a future trip.
But there is a perception among some U.S. lawmakers that the U.S. and China are locked in an unspoken space race that Americans are losing, a concern that prompted officials like Congressmen Tom Delay and Frank Wolf to call on Griffin to produce by month’s end an official NASA assessment of China’s space ambitions.
Admittedly, the ingredients of a space race akin to the Cold War-era competition between the U.S. and former Soviet Union seem to be there:
Both the U.S. and China want to put astronauts back on the Moon and both national space programs face major challenges over the next few years.
China must demonstrate ever-greater capabilities such as spacewalks, orbital rendezvous and docking, and space station construction…not the least of which is the development of its heavy-lift Long March 5 rocket and launching more than two astronauts at a time.
NASA, meanwhile, must contend with a retirement-bound shuttle fleet, funding limits, major commitments to complete the International Space Station, and a potential Hubble servicing mission. Oh and don’t forget the development of a brand new space transportation system that blends shuttle era, Apollo era and current technology into a functional Crew Exploration Vehicle and Crew Launch Vehicle…no small task, for sure.
China’s space program is a symbol of technological pride for the Communist nation, but two manned launches in two years - with another two-year gap expected - hardly a space race makes. Neither do NASA’s two shuttle flights since January 2003 (China’s first manned spaceflight Shenzhou 5 launched in October of that year) now that the U.S. agency knows – post-Columbia accident - that its orbiters are much more fragile machines than previously thought.
I’m not trying to discount the space accomplishments of either China or NASA – which are considerable, as human spaceflight is complex and risky - and a joint U.S.-China spaceflight could be every bit as significant as 1975’s Apollo-Soyuz mission, especially given the political chasm between the two. But to me the definition of a space race is two entities vying for the same goal – say the Moon – at a particular point in history when they not only are forging new territory, but have also caught the national interest of their respective citizens.
That what made the Cold War-era space race The Space Race, and today’s China-U.S. space activities largely a game of catch up for both nations. China is racing across 45 years of manned spaceflight to build up its own expertise, while NASA is racing with itself to try and reach a lost Moon.